Is definitely Honor Killing a Muslim Trend?
In communities where there is a excessive occurrence of honor killings, there is a powerful shared belief that reverance is the primary value is obviously. Honor eliminating is defined as the murder of any family or community member by other members because of the belief the victim brought shame after the relatives or community. In these residential areas, people use the concepts of honor and shame in an effort to assess and keep a certain standard of conduct. Although honor eradicating is not just a solely Muslim phenomenon, it includes increasingly become associated with Muslim societies. In his article, " Is Prize Killing a ‘Muslim Phenomenon'? Textual Interpretations and Ethnical Representations, ” Recep Dogan (2011) demonstrates the misinterpretations and misrepresentations through the evaluation of certain Qur'anic passages that finally create a setting conducive for the practice of honor killings. According to the author, these awareness make Muslims more likely to look and to display the typical features of reverance killings. Having a Bachelor of Islamic theology at Ankara University in Turkey, Recep Dogan is known as a prominent Muslim scholar, writer, and a respected community activist nationwide. With the very clear style of writing and easy to understand vocabulary that Dogan uses in the content, it is likely that Dogan's intended target audience is Westerners who are not well educated regarding honor killings and or Islam. Dogan's content is very structured with an intro and a collection of clear points that this individual uses to excercise his main argument. Dogan introduces the idea of honor frist by defining this from its beginnings and then identifying honor in a way that inspires eradicating. From there, the writer then goes into his main argument. Dogan uses historical sources like the Qu'ran and Hadith to support his claims. Together with the notion that honor getting rid of is not really solely a ‘Muslim Phenomenon', Dogan argues different interpretation of a lot of Qur'anic poems result in the" …denigration from the social position of women and also to the misperception and misconception of women and the sexuality, and which, in turn, are favorable to the creation of an environment in Muslim communities that contributes, in certain sense, for the practice of honor killings(p. 424). ” In other words the interpretations of certain Qur'anic verses provide Muslims a bad reputation with regards to honor killings. Dogan concludes that these awareness result from specific interpretations from the Qu'ran that consider a female's sexuality to be the main method to obtain " potential stress or potential threat” to relatives honor. Dogan uses a wide variety of sources along with historical text messaging, the Hadith and Qu'ran to support his argument. Dogan's use of academic evidence backs his claims which eventually strengthen his article. The sources Dogan uses appear to be reliable and knowledgeable for the topic of Islam and honor killings. Dogan'stone in the document comes through his writing and also through the headings Dogan uses. For example , a single section mind is permitted " Women as Source of Pollution” exactly where Dogan uses a Qur'anic sentirse that covers menstruation and just how a woman menstruating is seen as ‘harmful'. The only weak point I perceive in this article is the fact Dogan does not provide the audience with feasible ways to eventually fix the reputation of Islam regarding the perception that prize killing is a " Muslim Phenomenon. ” Instead Dogan notes that Islam is lacking in a central supreme authority " …that can give one last word upon conflicting concerns and understanding, and because it takes literacy and a knowledge…many people lack the mental capacity to assess the propriety or justifiability of their inappropriate actions against women” (p. 436. ) With that in mind, Dogan has an total strong document with concepts and quarrels that help the field of Islam. Since Dogan usually spends the first few portions defining reverance by the Latin root base, motives and reasoning behind honor...
References: Doğan, Ur. (2011). Is Honor Getting rid of a " Muslim Phenomenon”? Textual Understanding and Ethnic Representations. Record Of Muslim Minority Affairs, 31(3), 423-440.