The Emerald Exploration Register for this kind of journal is available at www.emeraldinsight.com/researchregister
The current issue and full text archive of this log is available at www.emeraldinsight.com/1463-7154.htm
Achievement and failing factors of
adopting SYSTEMS APPLICATIONS AND PRODUCTS in ENTERPRISE RESOURCE PLANNING system
Vidyaranya W. Gargeya
inability factors of
The University of North Carolina in Greensboro, Greensboro,
North Carolina, UNITED STATES, and
Volvo Trucks America, Greensboro, North Carolina, USA
Purpose вЂ“ Enterprise reference planning (ERP) systems will be software packages that allow companies to have even more real time presence and control of their functions. This conventional paper aims to research and analyze common instances that occur within the majority of ERP assignments, and determines the areas that are key to success compared to those that bring about failure.
Design/methodology/approach вЂ“ The analysis is based on a content evaluation of printed articles revealing SAP implementations in forty-four companies.
Conclusions вЂ“ Identiп¬Ѓes six common factors which have been indicative of successful or perhaps non-successful SYSTEMS APPLICATIONS AND PRODUCTS implementations. It has been found which the lack of appropriate culture and organizational (internal) readiness as the most important factor leading to failure of SAP implementations in 15 companies. Arsenic intoxication project management approaches and appropriate tradition and company (internal) openness are the most important factors leading to the success of SAP implementations in 29 businesses.
Research limitations/implications вЂ“ The info analyzed can be from secondary sources posted in the press. Secondary credit reporting could increase objectivity; however , the weak point is that only a few the factors might have been reported.
Originality/value вЂ“ Identiп¬Ѓes elements critical towards the success of SAP implementation Keywords Production resource organizing, Critical success factors Conventional paper type Exploration paper
Enterprise-wide reference planning (ERP) system software applications are highly bundled, complex devices for businesses, and thousands of companies are running these people successfully around the world (Koch, 1996). Even businesses such as Hershey, JoAnn shops, Whirlpool and Samsonite that have suffered through classic unfortunate occurances, acknowledge the application packages can handle the task. The devices are capable of working as marketed; however , businesses run into costly and sometimes fatal difп¬Ѓculties together with the implementation and subsequent repair of these packages.
According to The Gartner Group, 70 percent of all ENTERPRISE RESOURCE PLANNING projects neglect to be totally implemented, possibly after 36 months (Gillooly, 1998). Typically, there is not any single primary cause responsible for a " failed implementationвЂќ, with out individual reason to be acknowledged for a good one. However, deп¬Ѓnitions of failure and success happen to be gray areas, lending to interpretation. You will discover generally two levels of inability: complete failures and incomplete
Business Process Management
Vol. 14 No . your five, 2005
queen Emerald Group Publishing Limited
DOI 10. 1108/14637150510619858
failures. In a complete failing, the task either was scuttled prior to implementation or failed and so miserably which the company experienced signiп¬Ѓcant long term п¬Ѓnancial harm. Those implementations considered partial failures typically resulted in tenuous adjustment techniques for the organization; creating some form of disruption in daily businesses. In the same vein, an ERP achievement can be a complete success вЂ“ one in which everything is herd without a hitch, or perhaps one in which will there are few alignment concerns, resulting in minimal inconvenience or downtime. Often, these situational circumstances which may have to be ironed out in the weeks and months following your " go-liveвЂќ date aren't severe enough to disturb the daily operations. You will find dozens of distributors of ENTERPRISE RESOURCE PLANNING systems. However , the top п¬Ѓve ERP program vendors will be SAP, Peoplesoft,...
References: Aladwani, A. M. (2001), " Change management strategies for effective ERP implementationвЂќ,
Business Method Management Log, Vol
Atkinson, H. (1999), " ERP software needs good planningвЂќ, Journal of Commerce, being unfaithful December,
Burns, Meters. (1999), " ERPs: a buyers' marketвЂќ, CAmagazine, Volume. 132 Number 7, pp. 37-45.
Organization Wire (2001), " Keebler sharpens demand planning operations with my SAPвЂќ, Source
Chain Management, 19 04.
Caldwell, N. (1998), " GTE goes solo upon SAP R/3вЂќ, Information Week, No . 685, p. 150.
Campbell, S. (1999), " Merisel gets powered by simply SAP ERPвЂќ, Computer Reseller News, nineteenth April,
Koch, C. (1996), " Flipping the switchвЂќ, CIO, Vol. being unfaithful No . 18.
CIO (2000), " Truly does ERP create a better organization? вЂќ, 15 February, pp. 114-24.
Collett, S. (1999a), " Rayovac charges in to SAP using a big bangвЂќ, ComputerWorld, twenty three August,
Collett, S. (1999b), " SAP gets stuck inside the spin cycleвЂќ, ComputerWorld, 8 November, s. 1 .
Davenport, T. (2000), Mission Essential вЂ“ Noticing the Promise of Enterprise Systems, Harvard
Business College Publishing, Boston, MA.
Jingle, L. (2001), " Modeling top administration inп¬‚uence about ES implementationвЂќ, Business Method
Management Log, Vol
Geishecker, L. (1999), " ERP vs best of breedвЂќ, Proper Management, 03, pp. 63-6.
Gillooly, C. (1998), " DisillusionmentвЂќ, Information Week, 18 February, pp. 46-56.
Huang, Z. and Palvia, S. (2001), " ERP execution issues in advanced and developing
countriesвЂќ, Business Method Management Record, Vol
Jesitus, J. (1997), " Modify management вЂ“ energy towards the peopleвЂќ, Sector Week, Vol. 246 No . 16,
Krippendorf, K. (1980), Articles Analysis вЂ“ An Introduction to its Strategy, Sage, Newbury
Levin, 3rd there’s r. (1998), " Faster ERP rolloutsвЂќ, Details Week, 13 July, g. 24.
Mabert, V. A., Soni, A. and Venkataramanan, M. A. (2000), " Enterprise source planning survey
of US making п¬ЃrmsвЂќ, Production and Products on hand Management Journal, Second
May well, L. (1998), " Major reasons of software job failureвЂќ, Crosstalk, July.
Mearian, L. (2000), " CEO: SAP installation caused problemsвЂќ, ComputerWorld, Vol. 34 Number 48,
Nah, Farreneheit. F., Lau, J. T. and Kuang, J. (2001), " Crucial factors intended for successful execution of
organization systemsвЂќ, Organization Process Managing Journal, Vol
Nash, T. S. (2000a), " An incredibly bad bet for medicine distributorвЂќ, ComputerWorld, 30 Oct, p. thirty six.
Nash, K. S. (2000b), " Corporations don't study from previous IT snafusвЂќ, ComputerWorld,
30 January, pp
O'Brien, G. (1999), " Business West's top rated 25 community companiesвЂќ, Business West, Volume. 16 No . 6, s. 28.
Osterland, A. (2000), " Blaming ERPвЂќ, CFO, January, pp. 89-93.
PR Newswire (2001), 21 May well.
Ptak, C. (2000), ENTERPRISE RESOURCE PLANNING вЂ“ Equipment, Techniques and Applications intended for Integrating the Supply Chain,
New York, NY, Street Lucie Press.
Sandoe, K., Corbitt, G. and Boykin, R. (2001), Enterprise The usage, Wiley, Ny, NY.
Shaw, M. (2000), " Every systems goвЂќ, Pulp & Paper, Vol. 74 Number 9.
Stedman, C. (1999), " ENTERPRISE RESOURCE PLANNING п¬‚ops point out user's plansвЂќ, ComputerWorld, 12-15 November, l. 1 .
Stein, T. (1998), " SAP installation scuttledвЂќ, Information Week, 26 January p. thirty four.
Themistocleous, Meters., Irani, Z. and O'Keefe, R. M. (2001), " ERP and application integrationвЂќ,
Business Process Management Journal, Vol
Umble, E. J. and Umble, M. (2001), " Business resource organizing systems: an assessment
implementation issues and crucial success factorsвЂќ, Proceedings from the 32nd Gross annual
Meeting from the Decision Sciences Institute, pp. 1109-11.
Vaughan, J. (1996), " Organization applicationsвЂќ, Software program Magazine, Vol. 16 Number 5, pp. 67-72.
Wheatley, M. (2000), " ENTERPRISE RESOURCE PLANNING disasters вЂ“ bet the organization and loseвЂќ, Financial Representative, 1 Drive,
Wilder, C. (1998), " Fake starts, solid п¬ЃnishesвЂќ, Details Week, 40 November, s. 41.
Zerega, B. (1997), " Supervision support essential for big bangвЂќ, InfoWorld, almost eight September, s. 100.